Whiskey Stones: Do They Work, and Which to Buy

Whiskey stones are a favorite home bar gift (US searches for them roughly triple in December), and the promise is simple: a cold drink that never gets watered down. Tests show they do less than that. Here's what they actually do, how they compare with steel cubes and ice, and what to buy.

Quick answer: whiskey stones work, but only a little. They take a few degrees off a pour without diluting it. In The Art of Manliness's test, stones took bourbon from 70°F to 62°F, and it was back to 65°F within 30 minutes. Ice took the same bourbon to 35°F. If you want whiskey cold, use one large ice sphere, such as from the Tovolo 2.5 in sphere molds. If you want it just below room temperature and undiluted, get stainless steel cubes, which chill more than soapstone.

ChillerHow coldDilutes?
Soapstone stonesDown a few degrees: 70°F to 62°F, back to 65°F in 30 minNo
Stainless steel cubesUp to 20°F cooler, for most of an hourNo
Ice cubes70°F to 35°F, under 45°F for 90 minYes, watery by about 90 min

Stone and ice figures are from The Art of Manliness's bourbon test; the steel figure is from Tasting Table.

Bourbon at 70 degrees F chilled with whiskey stones fell to 62 F after a minute and was back to 65 F by 30 minutes; with ice cubes it fell to 35 F and stayed under 45 F for 90 minutes 40°F 50°F 60°F 70°F 0 30 60 90 120 minutes Whiskey stones Ice cubes Bourbon temperature after chilling
Bourbon at 70°F chilled with whiskey stones or ice cubes, from The Art of Manliness's test.

Why stones don't chill much

Ice cools a drink twice over: it starts at freezing, then soaks up a lot more heat as it melts. Stones only have the first part. Glew Engineering tested soapstone rocks against ice in 26°C (79°F) water. Four rocks got it down to 23.2°C (74°F); four ice cubes got it to 5.8°C (42°F). Their rocks started at 9.6°C (49°F), warmer than a freezer, so stones straight from the freezer do a little better. Their verdict still stands: if you want your drink cold, use ice.

How to choose

  1. Decide what you want. Cold whiskey means ice; a slightly cool, undiluted pour means stones or steel.
  2. Pick steel over soapstone for more chill. Steel cubes with liquid inside get colder and stay cold longer.
  3. Use one big piece of ice, not several small ones. A single 2.5 in sphere has less surface for its size, so it melts more slowly than the same ice as cubes.
  4. Get tongs with steel cubes. Frozen metal is unpleasant to pick up with bare fingers.
  5. Keep them in the freezer, so they're ready when you pour.

What to buy

PickKey specsWhy
Tovolo sphere ice molds
Coldest drink
2.5 in spheres; silicone with a silicone lid; BPA-free; dishwasher safe; sets of 2 or 4Gets whiskey properly cold, with slower dilution than cubes
ZYNERY stainless steel cubes
Best stones
12 cubes, 1.1 in; 304 stainless steel filled with ethanol and water; freeze 2 to 3 hours; tray, tongs and bagMore chill than soapstone, no dilution, and cheap
Teroforma Whisky Stones
Best gift
9 soapstone stones; made in the USA; freeze at least 4 hours; muslin bagThe original whisky stones, for a gift that looks the part

Tovolo specs are from Kitchen Kapers ($14.99 for 2 at the time of writing), ZYNERY's from Walmart ($10.17) and Teroforma's from Advanced Mixology ($87.49). The ZYNERY and Teroforma sets were out of stock there when we checked, so look at the listing before you buy.

Pour over them in a heavy-bottomed glass from our whiskey glasses guide, and keep the bottle in a decanter on the bar cart.

Whiskey stones FAQ

Do whiskey stones actually work?

Only a little. In The Art of Manliness's test, whiskey stones took bourbon from 70°F to 62°F, and it was back up to 65°F within 30 minutes. Ice cubes took the same bourbon to 35°F. Stones are for taking the edge off a pour without watering it down, not for a cold drink.

Are stainless steel whiskey stones better than soapstone?

They chill more. Tasting Table says steel cubes can drop a drink by as much as 20°F and keep it cold for most of an hour, while soapstone cools less and for less time. Steel cubes also freeze faster: the ZYNERY set takes 2 to 3 hours against at least 4 for Teroforma's soapstone.

How do you use whiskey stones?

Rinse them, let them dry, and freeze them for a few hours: at least 4 for soapstone, 2 to 3 for steel. Put two or three in a glass before you pour. Afterwards, wash them, let them dry, and put them back in the freezer for next time.